Restless Beings
Photograph courtesy of ParadiseintheWorld
With growing scepticism of foreign involvement in domestic affairs,
many developing states are beginning to implement policies limiting
international presence; from international aid and NGOs to Corporate
Investment. However, in the immensely interdependent world, especially
due to the state many countries have been left in from colonial
exploitation and its lingering influence, this is a luxury that certain
leaders feel their people cannot afford.
Ethiopia is one of these nations that, instead of reducing the
permeability of its borders in view of endogenous domestic progression
as a priority, have in recent times opted to open itself up to outside
help; being further at the whim of global forces. One such example of
this dynamic is the ‘Gibe III’ hydro-electric dam that is currently
under construction. It is located on the Lower Omo River Valley region,
in the South-West of Ethiopia, and is being built by the Italian company
‘Salini Costruttori’ and part funded by the Chinese bank ‘ICBC’.
The region is home to some eight different tribes of a population
estimated to be around 200,000. There are grave concerns that this will
lead to the rapid degradation of the fragile ecosystem and the
livelihoods of the tribes who maintain a close affinity with the river
and its cycles. The annual flooding of the river is essential
to the biodiversity of the region and, with generally low and erratic
rainfall, the food security of the tribal people. The culture of
subsistence farming, grazing livestock, hunting and fishing is at severe
risk. ‘Flood retreat agriculture’ has been developed over generations
and the aggregation of complex ecological practices that are dynamic to
the harsh conditions provide stability to the Bodi (Me’en), Daasanach,
Kara (or Karo), Kwegu (or Muguji), Mursi and Nyangatom people, in
particular, that live along the Omo.
Since 2011 large areas of this fertile land have been leased out to
Transnational Corporations by the government. While this may lead to the
illusion of growth and progression for the nation, the reality is the
cash crops grown on the land are actually diminishing the capacity of
the people rather than increasing it. Capital flows out the country and
those marginalised by the process become dependent on aid for survival.
There are also further plans to form irrigation canals that will divert
the waters in the favour of agri-business plantations, at the detriment
of the local communities. Swathes of indigenous people have been
forcibly resettled with those opposing the de facto theft of their land
reported to be beaten and thrown in jail. This has even involved alleged
raping and killing by the Ethiopian Defence Force that patrol the
region in view of safeguarding the construction process.
It is apparent that the government is turning a blind eye to the goings
on around the Lower Omo Valley, which is actually already a UNESCO
World Heritage site. Ethiopian law
dictates the required completion of an environmental and social impact
assessment (ESIA) before any project approval, as well as the Ethiopian
Constitution guaranteeing tribes ‘full consultation’ in the
environmental policies and ‘projects that affect them directly’. The
reality, however, is that two years after the start of construction the
Ethiopian Environmental Protection Agency retrospectively granted
approval of the ESIA, which was dubiously facilitated by an Italian
company, CESI, and funded by an Ethiopian energy corporation. The
indigenous communities have rarely been contacted throughout this
process, with the majority having next to no knowledge about the
project, and with the Justice Bureau even revoking 41 ‘Community
Association’ licenses in July 2009 for not cooperating with government
policy.
The largest two donors to Ethiopia, The USA and UK, have failed to
investigate allegations of these human rights abuses in connection with
the project, despite their contact with the Bodi and Mursi
representatives. Away from the lack of international solidarity, the
voice of the indigenous people remains disarticulated from the bottom-up
as a result of the 2009 decree that prevents any NGO that receives more
than 10% foreign funding from promoting human rights and democracy.
With the suppression of the tribespeople leaving them with little room
for manoeuvre or agency for change, inter-ethnic conflict has the
potential to flare up in competition for the dwindling resources. The
Valley peoples have had a history of relative harmony and positive
exchange, but this is deteriorating with periodic inter-ethnic conflicts as more and more land is being taken away; as well as the appearance of firearms intensifying the fighting.
Independent expert evaluation
has shown how the Omo River in its natural flow is a lifeline to the
varying ecosystems and the livelihood of the peoples of the Valley
region. Whilst the project may be pushed through in the name of
sustainable development, these types of large scale top-down development
projects are often blunt instruments and can cause more harm to the
poor than good. In Ethiopia the needs and rights of the Omo River people
are being categorically denied and their functioning culture is being
eradicated under the influence of Transnational Corporate forces and
corrupt elites. The potential for water wars and mass hunger are not to
be taken lightly. Some major international institutions have already
distanced themselves from the project and the growing petition to support the tribes people
is not in vain. Greater international solidarity is required to achieve
social justice, especially as the power of local people to deter
damaging projects and stop this man-made disaster cannot be
underestimated.
Δεν υπάρχουν σχόλια:
Δημοσίευση σχολίου